← Back to Home

Perceptual Study: Text-to-HDR Generation

20 HDR images generated by LEDiff, Bracket Diffusion, and our method (SD-1.5 and Flux) for perceptual study.

JOD low and high represent 95% confidence interval estimated via bootstrapping.

20
Visible Prompts
4
Active Methods
80
Total Images
0
Missing Images
LEDiffBracket DiffusionOurs (SD-1.5)Ours (Flux)
Example #1
LEDiff - Prompt 1
JOD -3.2731
JOD_high -2.3023
JOD_low -6.6798
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 1
JOD -1.0741
JOD_high -0.9912
JOD_low -1.3771
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 1
JOD 2.11
JOD_high 4.02
JOD_low 1.42
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 1
JOD 2.24
JOD_high 4.00
JOD_low 1.61
Ours (Flux)
Example #2
LEDiff - Prompt 2
JOD -3.0078
JOD_high -2.3044
JOD_low -5.9181
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 2
JOD -1.3176
JOD_high -1.0183
JOD_low -1.9343
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 2
JOD 2.60
JOD_high 4.85
JOD_low 1.92
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 2
JOD 1.72
JOD_high 3.44
JOD_low 1.21
Ours (Flux)
Example #3
LEDiff - Prompt 3
JOD -1.8238
JOD_high -1.3977
JOD_low -2.9100
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 3
JOD 0.4620
JOD_high 0.9840
JOD_low 0.0383
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 3
JOD -0.0001
JOD_high 0.7116
JOD_low -0.5093
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 3
JOD 1.36
JOD_high 1.94
JOD_low 1.01
Ours (Flux)
Example #4
LEDiff - Prompt 4
JOD -2.2828
JOD_high -1.8480
JOD_low -3.9671
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 4
JOD -0.4209
JOD_high 0.0558
JOD_low -1.0842
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 4
JOD 1.06
JOD_high 2.35
JOD_low 0.5849
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 4
JOD 1.64
JOD_high 2.87
JOD_low 1.31
Ours (Flux)
Example #5
LEDiff - Prompt 5
JOD -3.4691
JOD_high -2.9200
JOD_low -4.6529
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 5
JOD -0.2826
JOD_high 0.0159
JOD_low -0.9833
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 5
JOD 1.01
JOD_high 2.18
JOD_low 0.2288
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 5
JOD 2.75
JOD_high 4.21
JOD_low 2.18
Ours (Flux)
Example #6
LEDiff - Prompt 6
JOD -3.8732
JOD_high -2.4690
JOD_low -14.6794
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 6
JOD -1.4020
JOD_high -0.9609
JOD_low -4.8931
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 6
JOD 1.80
JOD_high 4.89
JOD_low 1.15
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 6
JOD 3.48
JOD_high 14.68
JOD_low 2.23
Ours (Flux)
Example #7
LEDiff - Prompt 7
JOD -2.5772
JOD_high -1.6655
JOD_low -4.9855
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 7
JOD -0.5425
JOD_high -0.0001
JOD_low -1.0690
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 7
JOD -0.0133
JOD_high 0.4867
JOD_low -0.4954
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 7
JOD 3.13
JOD_high 4.99
JOD_low 2.58
Ours (Flux)
Example #8
LEDiff - Prompt 8
JOD -2.2464
JOD_high -1.7432
JOD_low -3.7331
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 8
JOD -0.5462
JOD_high -0.0325
JOD_low -1.1960
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 8
JOD 1.04
JOD_high 2.03
JOD_low 0.5578
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 8
JOD 1.75
JOD_high 2.76
JOD_low 1.26
Ours (Flux)
Example #9
LEDiff - Prompt 9
JOD -3.1645
JOD_high -2.2476
JOD_low -13.4082
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 9
JOD -1.5598
JOD_high -0.9891
JOD_low -4.4694
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 9
JOD 3.22
JOD_high 13.41
JOD_low 2.28
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 9
JOD 1.51
JOD_high 4.47
JOD_low 0.9696
Ours (Flux)
Example #10
LEDiff - Prompt 10
JOD -2.6579
JOD_high -2.1829
JOD_low -4.9901
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 10
JOD -0.7444
JOD_high -0.2361
JOD_low -1.8678
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 10
JOD 1.20
JOD_high 2.59
JOD_low 1.02
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 10
JOD 2.21
JOD_high 4.54
JOD_low 1.47
Ours (Flux)
Example #11
LEDiff - Prompt 11
JOD -1.6879
JOD_high -1.3112
JOD_low -2.6681
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 11
JOD -0.2906
JOD_high 0.3464
JOD_low -0.8561
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 11
JOD 1.31
JOD_high 1.97
JOD_low 0.8637
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 11
JOD 0.6689
JOD_high 1.21
JOD_low 0.2321
Ours (Flux)
Example #12
LEDiff - Prompt 12
JOD -1.1237
JOD_high -0.6322
JOD_low -1.8798
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 12
JOD -0.6119
JOD_high -0.2555
JOD_low -1.1322
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 12
JOD 0.3673
JOD_high 1.11
JOD_low -0.2155
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 12
JOD 1.37
JOD_high 1.91
JOD_low 1.01
Ours (Flux)
Example #13
LEDiff - Prompt 13
JOD -3.6196
JOD_high -3.2563
JOD_low -13.2434
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 13
JOD -2.9341
JOD_high -2.1331
JOD_low -4.4334
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 13
JOD 1.14
JOD_high 4.41
JOD_low 0.9632
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 13
JOD 5.42
JOD_high 13.24
JOD_low 4.56
Ours (Flux)
Example #14
LEDiff - Prompt 14
JOD -5.3000
JOD_high -4.4492
JOD_low -13.5656
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 14
JOD -1.1233
JOD_high -0.9319
JOD_low -4.5219
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 14
JOD 2.83
JOD_high 4.52
JOD_low 2.04
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 14
JOD 3.60
JOD_high 13.57
JOD_low 3.24
Ours (Flux)
Example #15
LEDiff - Prompt 15
JOD -3.0676
JOD_high -2.2057
JOD_low -5.1065
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 15
JOD 0.0926
JOD_high 0.4099
JOD_low -0.3459
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 15
JOD -0.3706
JOD_high 0.1015
JOD_low -0.9105
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 15
JOD 3.35
JOD_high 5.11
JOD_low 2.86
Ours (Flux)
Example #16
LEDiff - Prompt 16
JOD -1.4517
JOD_high -0.9647
JOD_low -2.1647
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 16
JOD -0.0838
JOD_high 0.3596
JOD_low -0.6069
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 16
JOD 0.5629
JOD_high 1.40
JOD_low -0.1197
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 16
JOD 0.9725
JOD_high 1.47
JOD_low 0.5780
Ours (Flux)
Example #17
LEDiff - Prompt 17
JOD -1.5118
JOD_high -1.0565
JOD_low -2.2416
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 17
JOD -0.8955
JOD_high -0.5245
JOD_low -1.5947
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 17
JOD 0.8772
JOD_high 1.82
JOD_low 0.3019
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 17
JOD 1.53
JOD_high 2.12
JOD_low 1.18
Ours (Flux)
Example #18
LEDiff - Prompt 18
JOD -2.7641
JOD_high -2.0010
JOD_low -4.3768
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 18
JOD -0.1909
JOD_high 0.4891
JOD_low -0.8987
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 18
JOD 0.1909
JOD_high 0.7377
JOD_low -0.3101
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 18
JOD 2.76
JOD_high 4.38
JOD_low 1.96
Ours (Flux)
Example #19
LEDiff - Prompt 19
JOD -2.1289
JOD_high -1.6984
JOD_low -2.4890
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 19
JOD -1.7321
JOD_high -1.2055
JOD_low -2.0815
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 19
JOD 1.73
JOD_high 2.13
JOD_low 1.14
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 19
JOD 2.13
JOD_high 2.49
JOD_low 1.86
Ours (Flux)
Example #20
LEDiff - Prompt 20
JOD -1.1287
JOD_high -0.7140
JOD_low -1.9705
LEDiff
Bracket Diffusion - Prompt 20
JOD -1.0403
JOD_high -0.6372
JOD_low -1.7318
Bracket Diffusion
Ours (SD-1.5) - Prompt 20
JOD 0.5004
JOD_high 1.39
JOD_low -0.0950
Ours (SD-1.5)
Ours (Flux) - Prompt 20
JOD 1.67
JOD_high 2.46
JOD_low 1.34
Ours (Flux)